Developed by Deconstructeam, Published by Digital Devolver
Despite invoking the gods in its title, thereâ€™s hardly any intelligent design present in this game.
The stability of the Constellar Federation is threatened by Xenolifer, a radical organization in possession of a lethal virus that could wipe out all life on a planet. To combat this menace, the Everdusk Company for the Universe Knowledge (E.C.U.K.) recruits decorated Sergeant Abraham Burden to infiltrate Xenolifer and gather information about the virus in the hopes of creating a cure. Billions of lives hang in the balance, their ultimate fate dependent on Burdenâ€™s actions.
From the start Gods Will Be Watching doesnâ€™t do much to impress players. The story is a fairly overdone space opera where a galaxy-spanning government force is embroiled in conflict with a rebel group, a struggle which can only be ended by the actions of one man. Even a clichÃ©d plot can work if the writers subvert the formula or create enough intrigue to draw you into their world, but this game does neither. Characters frequently discuss the evils theyâ€™re dedicated to fighting against (or in some cases for) â€“ the Constellar Federationâ€™s policy of treating non-human species as slaves, Xenoliferâ€™s acts that cause some to view them as terrorists and others as freedom fighters, the barely touched upon Hollistic Empire which is described as a brutal, despotic regime â€“ yet none of this is ever seen. Thereâ€™s nothing to grab your attention. Even for a game which was intended to showcase minimalism, the rule of â€œshow, donâ€™t tellâ€ should still apply.
Deconstructeam promoted Gods Will Be Watching as a title centered on â€œdespair, commitment, and sacrifice,â€ yet fails to realize any of these concepts. Throughout each of the seven missions Burden is faced with incredibly difficult decisions which will affect those around him, usually his crew members or hostages. Scenarios typically involve managing rations, keeping team morale high, or intimidating enemies to make them give up important information. There are several moments, most notably in situations where resources are running low, when the player is presented with the possibility that allowing some to die for the sake of others is the best option. Should a few suffer and perish for the greater good? Is killing one so many might live cruel or pragmatic?
This is a great moral dilemma and one that video games rarely touch upon. However, the potential ethical quandaries are rendered moot by one massive mistake. If any member of Burdenâ€™s team dies in one chapter, they will be present in the next simply because the plot requires them to have a role. This takes away any chance of a deep, thought-provoking analysis on the concept of sacrifice and the needs of many versus the needs of few, as well as removing any possible drama or suspense in a situation where it looks like an ally may die. Since none of your allies can be killed off for good, you only really need to focus on keeping Burden alive to complete a chapter. Itâ€™s impossible to convey themes of commitment and sacrifice when the central priority is looking out for yourself.
As a final narrative failure, all of the characters are bland, forgettable non-entities. Only two are given vague attempts at personality and backstory, both very poorly executed. Sergeant Burden, the protagonist, is nothing more than what fan fiction writers would call a â€œMarty Stu,â€ practically flawless and insufferably dull. He inspires awe from allies and enemies, makes all the heroic decisions, and has a dark, mysterious backstory which, without spoiling much, makes absolutely no sense and is never explained. Liam, the leader of Xenolifer, could have been interesting if they took the time to explore his motivations, what pushed him from civil disobedience to planning mass murder. Burden even expresses sympathy for Liamâ€™s cause, hoping to sway him from violence, but all their interactions boil down to little more than trite pseudo-philosophical banter on the nature of humanity and what lines must be crossed for the good of all. Every side character is completely forgettable, existing solely to spout exposition or heavy handed social and political ideologies. Making their dialogue more insufferable are the numerous spelling and grammar errors in the English translation, from stilted sentences and incorrect tense use to completely absurd lines like â€œWeâ€™ll have to dosify smartly our efforts.â€
Gameplay is an odd hybrid of point-and-click adventure and turn-based strategy. In each chapter you have to make several decisions, observe their outcome after execution, then tailor the next set of choices based on the results. Time management, job delegation, rationing supplies and behavioral modification all play a role in the outcomes obtained. Itâ€™s a clever concept ruined because the developers allowed for random negative outcomes. Several actions show the probability of success based on preparation, but even if thereâ€™s a 90% chance that a bluff will deceive an interrogator or prevent a computerâ€™s security system from being hacked, you could still fail and suffer a setback.
Making things worse are the instances that come as a complete surprise. In the first chapter you need to watch over a group of hostages, intimidating them so they donâ€™t revolt while keeping them calm enough to avoid making a suicidal run for freedom. Ideally their body language and statements should make it easy to see how far on either end of the spectrum they are and whether more cruelty or compassion is required to keep them in line, but sometimes theyâ€™ll attempt to run without warning, even if they seemed relatively relaxed. Chapter 4 presents the threat of wild animals that can raid your camp and kill everyone if there isnâ€™t enough ammunition to drive them off, but thereâ€™s no warning about what nights theyâ€™ll strike and no chance to prepare. I could understand if this was intended to be a metaphor about how even the best plans can go awry due to events you have no control over, but in a game that emphasizes the importance of planning and strategy, it gives you the impression that youâ€™re wasting your time, that no matter how well youâ€™re doing you can die whenever the game wants you to.
The most painful part of failing a mission is starting the entire chapter from the beginning. Thereâ€™s no chance to manually save, no guarantee that a strategy that almost carried you to the end the first time will work again. Itâ€™s egregious padding, and not the only time itâ€™s used. During the second chapter when Burden is being interrogated under threat of torture, his captor will repeat questions that have already been asked and answered because the section needs to continue until its predetermined end point. The final section, the battle between Burden and Liam, is drawn out to the point of frustration. Liam has several attacks that can kill you in one hit which are never telegraphed, and always follow the same pattern. Defeating him requires you to die several times just to memorize the order of his attacks and know how to counter them. This is bad design, another example of how luck and endurance are more important to victory than skill. And there are several bugs that can lead to mission failure and force a replay of a chapter. The worst I ran into was when I had to play a Mastermind-inspired game to find a cure for the Medusea virus, figuring out the right compounds and the order they need to go in. I got three of them in the right locations, but was then told that the final compound, while correct, was out of sequence, even though it was in the only remaining open spot.
Visuals are very unappealing. Iâ€™m not a snob whoâ€™s opposed to pixel art and games that go for a retro aesthetic, but there at least has to be effort put into the art. Character models have nothing resembling faces, the levels are either dull wilderness or generic spacecraft that have dozens of monitors lining their walls, and the limited animations make it difficult to read body language. Sound design is just as unimpressive, nothing but a collection of electronic clicks, beeps and other assorted effects from the Atari-5200 era.
The entirety of Gods Will Be Watching can best be summarized by its second chapter, the torture scene. Itâ€™s a long, painful, repetitive experience that just expects you to ride it out to the end no matter how bad things get. The only people who could possibly be interested in playing this game would have to be masochists. There is nothing redeeming about Gods Will Be Watching. It is not worth your money or the hours it will steal from you.